Google

Thursday, December 23, 2004

THE PICTURE SAYS IT ALL

Thomas Friedman in the New York Times points our attention to a picture we saw this week that says it all about the war in Iraq...

It showed several Iraqi gunmen, in broad daylight and without masks, murdering two Iraqi election workers. The murder scene was a busy street in the heart of Baghdad. The two election workers had been dragged from their car into the middle of the street. They looked young, the sort of young people you'd see doing election canvassing in America or Ukraine or El Salvador.

One was kneeling with his arms behind his back, waiting to be shot in the head. Another was lying on his side. The gunman had either just pumped a bullet into him or was about to. I first saw the picture on the Internet, and I did something I've never done before - I blew it up so it covered my whole screen. I wanted to look at it more closely. You don't often get to see the face of pure evil.


There is much to dislike about this war in Iraq, but there is no denying the stakes. And that picture really framed them: this is a war between some people in the heart of the Arab-Muslim world who - for the first time ever in their region - are trying to organize an election to choose their own leaders and write their own constitution versus all the forces arrayed against them.

Do not be fooled into thinking that the Iraqi gunmen in this picture are really defending their country and have no alternative. The Sunni-Baathist minority that ruled Iraq for so many years has been invited, indeed begged, to join in this election and to share in the design and wealth of post-Saddam Iraq.


As the Johns Hopkins foreign policy expert Michael Mandelbaum so rightly pointed out to me, "These so-called insurgents in Iraq are the real fascists, the real colonialists, the real imperialists of our age." They are a tiny minority who want to rule Iraq by force and rip off its oil wealth for themselves. It's time we called them by their real names.

However this war started, however badly it has been managed, however much you wish we were not there, do not kid yourself that this is not what it is about: people who want to hold a free and fair election to determine their own future, opposed by a virulent nihilistic minority that wants to prevent that. That is all that the insurgents stand for.

Read the whole thing, and remember that picture the next time you hear someone refer to the insurgents as "freedom fighters" or "Iraq's Minutemen" (as Michael Moore did).

1 Comments:

At 5:50 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Come on with the "pure evil" stuff Dan. God isn't on our side or their side. As an American I too feel horrified by such a terrible act. No backing off that. But many ultra-right wingers ar going to bring down the whole conservative movement by the mistake of making everything religious, or described in religious terms. I don't take issue with your point, it needs to be made. May I suggest you lay off the "evil" vs. "good" talk, cause that is going to hurt your arguement. In the long run, your boy Hannity is going to be looked at as the same type of manipulator as Father Coughlin in the 1920's and 30's. It's not that he's wrong about his strong conservative beliefs, it's that he panders with the religious descriptions. To out enemys WE are the evil-doers and they openly describe God being on their side. Tis a mistake to go this route over the long run. Good luck. You're a good man.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home