Google

Sunday, January 20, 2008

NEVADA AND S.C ANALYSIS

Two more down, many more to go.

In Nevada, Hillary Clinton and Mitt Romney were the winners. Here are the results. For Romney, it was no surprise. The state has a significant Mormon constituency and Romney was the only Republican who gave it any serious attention. For Clinton, it was another example of how she is winning the traditional Democratic coalition, which bodes very well for her going forward. As Jay Cost points out in his analysis, she is winning women, Catholics, people who make under $50,000 a year, and now she can add Hispanics to the list. Obama continues to win upper-income voters, he does well with men, and very well with African-Americans. But he doesn't win the male vote by enough to counteract Clinton's strength with women, and there are still more lower income voters in the Democratic Party than upper-income. While Obama may be able to win South Carolina next Saturday, if Clinton continues to win the traditional Democratic voters, she is going to do very well on Super Tuesday, and will win the nomination.

In South Carolina, were only the GOP primary was held yesterday, John McCain pulled out a narrow victory. Here are the results. Jay Cost also analyzes those results, and concludes that Mike Huckabee did not appeal very well beyond his evangelical base. This does not bode well for him going forward. Still, he might have won South Carolina were it not for Fred Thompson. Ironically, if Thompson stays in for the Florida primary on the 29th, that might actually help Huckabee. Right now the Florida polls show a four-way tie, essentially, between McCain, Giuliani, Huckabee and Romney. Thompson gets just enough non-evangelical conservative voters that might otherwise go to Romney, which prevents him from busting out past Huckabee (as I think Giuliani keeps McCain from busting out, and Giuliani does the same to McCain, as they take from each other).

As it stands now, the only thing standing in the way of John McCain winning the nomination is the possibility that enough candidates will drop out quickly enough to leave only one conservative alternative standing with enough time to reach the finish line first. The only two candidates who can make the case that they are reliably conservative (and more conservative than the maverick McCain) on all the important fiscal, social and national security issues are Fred Thompson and Mitt Romney. It seems that Romney is the only one who can now offer the alternative to McCain with enough money and enough wins in his pocket to make the case that he can unite the GOP and beat him to that delegate finish line. For McCain, the path to victory is to keep Thompson and Huckabee in the race and eliminate Giuliani in Florida. That looks like the best bet.

1 Comments:

At 3:04 PM, Blogger blahga the hutt said...

Technically, Obama won with a 13-12 delegate margin. In South Carolina, the race wasn't as close as it seems because McCain picked up 19 of 24 delegates, which is a blowout. Since it is ultimately delegates, not the voters, who will decide the nomination, it seems puzzling to me that the media continues to look at the voter percentages as the indicator of victory. Even New Hampshire was a tie (9-9 in delegates, with Edwards gettign 4).

The Edwards factor could skew the delegate count going into the primary, since Clinton holds only a slight edge against Edwards/Obama (which is how it should be read at this point).

In the Republican race, SC was a big hurt for Huckabee. It proves that the evangelical base is not at all monolithic and that will cause problems for him later on. Momentum seems to be shifting away from Huckabee (and perhaps Giuliani) and more towards Romney and McCain. Thompson is done. He needed a much better finish than 3rd place (and no delegates) and I would be surprised if he doesn't announce his resignation from the race later this week. His speech in SC last night sounded more like a withdrawal than a continuation.

Mat - politiblahg.blogger.com

 

Post a Comment

<< Home